HomeFood & drinkFisherman's Pie

Fisherman's Pie

No rating at the moment! Be the first to
Origin of dish:  UK
Type of cooking:  Oven
Preparation time: 0 minutes
Ingredients (for 4 to 6 people) :

    - 2 fillets of any fish of your choice - firm fish works best but it can be anything from pollack, cod, haddock or salmon etc roughly 600g
    - 1 fillet of a smoked fish for flavour - about 200g
    - 2 Hard Boiled Eggs - peeled and quartered
    - 1kg Maris Piper Potatoes


    -20g Orkney cheddar - grated
    - 1 egg- for egg wash

    - Hard Boiled Eggs

    Cover eggs with water and place over heat. Bring to a boil and take off the heat. Allow to sit for 10 minutes and then cool before peeling.

    Court Bouillon

    - 1 Lt water
    - 2 cups white wine
    - Juice of 1 lemon
    - 1 bouquet garni
    - Salt
    - Cracked Black Pepper


    - 60g butter
    - 4 tbsp flour
    - 500ml milk
    - 2 tbsp Grain Mustard
    - 100g Orkney cheddar - grated


Béchamel sauce

First bring the milk up to a simmer in a small pot and set aside.

Next in another pan, melt the butter gently over medium heat, then add flour and stir until the mixture is smooth.

Now begin adding the milk a little at a time to avoid lumps. Keep adding milk and stirring, until you have a rich creamy sauce.

Allow to cook slowly for 5 minutes and then add the grain mustard and Orkney cheddar.

Mix well and set aside.


Add all the ingredients of the Court Bouillon in a large deep sauce pan. Bring to a gentle simmer before adding your fish to gently poach. Remembering to poach the smoked fish last.

Once cooked through, remove from liquid, let cool and remove any bones and skin.

Flake fish into nice small pieces and set aside.

Mashed potato

Pre heat the oven to 200°C/Gas 6. Place the potatoes on a tray and bake in a hot oven until crispy and soft.

While still hot, scoop out the flesh, discard the skins and pass the potato through a drum sieve to remove any lumps.

Heat the milk used for poaching the fish previously and add 2 tbsp butter and fold through potato mixture. Season to taste.


Preheat the oven to 190°C/Gas 5. Butter a baking dish and start to make the pie by first spreading a small amount of bechamel on the bottom of the dish.

On top of that spread the poached fish and quartered eggs.

Spread with the remaining bechamel.

Top with the mashed potatoes and brush with an egg wash and sprinkle with grated cheese.

Place baking dish on a tray and put into a preheated gas mark 5 oven for 30-40 minutes or until golden brown and bubbling.
Recipe shared by soFeminineTeam
Recipe(s) from the same person
Advice: This is an Orkney Cheddar recipe.

User comments

another free recipe every day

More recipes:
Rhubarb crumble with ginger
Queen Elizabeth Date Cake
Ham, spinach and egg pie
Steak with Broad Bean and Spinach Salad
Superfast Superfood Salad
Smoked Greek Salad
Choice Superfood Salad
Raw Salad
Caesar Potato Salad
Halloumi Salad with Herby Yogurt Dressing

Latest… 24/05/2019
Stop Everything! A Real-life Nutella Tap Exists
See all Food and Drink videos

Don't miss out!

...Join our newsletter
Get the sofeminine latest straight to your inbox
Find us on...